I wanted:
- to briefly summarise my thoughts / experience, and
- to ask if anyone has found a better way to use a second, "hidden" Whatsapp on a phone
I know there are quite a few topics on this already, but I have not found any with the level of detail I'd like.
A separate punting phoneNot a big fan of the idea. Even when justifying it is not an issue, I find it's a hassle to have a separate phone to carry around. Of course YMMV (your mileage may vary).
Dual-sim phones:I am not a big fan of this. Too risky. A previous employer gave me a dual-sim phone so we could put both private and work sim in, and lots of people would always make confusion, calling private contacts from the work number and viceversa. The risk of confusion is just too high.
The hushed appI think it's great because it is an app that you log in and out of. If you are logged out, there is no way you can receive a text or call. The call quality is a bit temperamental at times; I wouldn't use it if you are self-employed and want a separate number for work, but as a punting number it is absolutely great. If you are really paranoid, unless you punt everyday, you can uninstall it when you don't use it and reinstall it when you need to call/text to make another booking.
Samsung Secure FolderMost unrooted Samsung phones have this great feature called "secure folder" - it's like a separate space on your phone where you can install apps and store files which are kept encrypted and separate from your main phone. Some Chinese manufacturers have something similar, too (dual apps, second space, etc)
I am not aware of reliable alternatives that work on all Androids (eg on a Motorola or Sony)
Hushed + secure folder is a great combination. You keep the Hushed app in the Secure Folder space, log out when you don't need it, and you have a perfect punting setup
Whatsapp + Secure FolderIn Samsung Secure Folder, you can install Whatsapp and link it to your Hushed number. Whatsapp will send you a verification text to your Hushed number but, after this, I understand Whatsapp has no clue you are using a Hushed number.
Some useful settings are:
- Whatsapp - 3 dots at the top right - settings - privacy - fingerprint lock (at the bottom). This way a dual verification is required to access your 2nd Whatsapp: first the password to log into Secure Folder, then biometrics to log into Whatsapp
- Secure Folder - 3 dots at the top right - settings - notifications and data - app notifications - disable Whatsapp.
With 2) you are disabling the notifications of your second Whatsapp in the SecureFolder, NOT of your main whatsapp linked to your main number. Up to you if you want to do it but I think it's useful. This way you won't risk a whatsapp notification when you give the phone to your elderly father so he can videocall Aunt Annie who has moved down under
With the phone set up this way, you will not receive any notification when someone tries to call you or text you on your hidden Whatspp. But if you enter secure folder and then whatsapp, you will see the texts/ missed calls there.
It would be better if Whatsapp had an option to log out, like Hushed does, but this is probably the best.
If you don't do 2), when you get a Whatsapp message you will receive a notification in the statusbar showing Whatsapp and a locked folder. If you click on it, it will ask you for the password to SecureFolder. Which I suppose is a risk most people will want to avoid.
Of course you can use 2) to block the notifications of any similar app (Signal, Telegram etc) you set up in Secure Folder
SecureFolder has an option to display or not display the content of the notification
Also, contacts are kept completely separate - the contacts I add to my hidden Whatsapp show up in the Contacts in Secure Folders but NOT on the "main" part of my phone.
Oh, and with SecureFolder I can have a hidden browser that keeps me logged into UKP
Whatsapp BusinessI haven't tried it, but, if I got this right, installing Whatsapp Business is the only way to have a second Whatsapp number on the same phone, if you don't have something like SecureFolder dual space etc.
You can set a biometric app lock for WA Business, and you can disable notifications in the Android settings, but I have no idea if the contacts you add to WA business get synced to your main contacts.
IphonesDon't now much about iphones, sorry. I understand from an older thread that on Iphones you can have a password-protected hidden browser, but you cannot hide and password protect an app like Hushed
https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=354071.msg3652237#msg3652237 Difference between Hushed and WhatsappIf I have both in SecureFolder, the main difference is of course that I can log out of Hushed but not out of Whatsapp.
So with Hushed I can keep notifications on and log out if I ever have to briefly share my phone with someone else. This also means that if a WG texts me I will see the notification straight away.
With Whatsapp I prefer to disable notifications altogether. This means I will not see it immediately if a WG messages me (I have to open the hidden Whatsapp and check) but I prefer it this way. YMMV.