This isn't a separate review, merely a reply to his own review confirming a second visit
I've done exactly the same in the past, I believe the rules are that you cannot start another fresh review if you've already left a positive review in the last 12 months
I am sure that one of the mods will either confirm or correct this
Yes, you're spot on.
Here's what site rules say exactly:
"Only one positive review thread can be posted for a service provider by one member per 12 month period, the exception is if the new positive review is for a threesome (or more) booking. This 12-month restriction only applies to positive reviews, not neutral or negative (they can be posted anytime after a positive review). During the 12-month period a member can add their new positive reviews to their existing review thread in the form of a reply."
Full rules here:
https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=1.0 (and at the bottom of every page)
Also note that there are no mods, only "helpers" who're just able to do very minor stuff such as moving topics and editing thread titles (which they have to justify) but for example they can't merge topics or edit posts etc, only admin can do that.
Two threads have been merged so now looks like Moreish was in the wrong but he was correct at the time.
That's a good point actually, I checked the topic move logs in an attempt to see if that had happened but obviously that won't show thread mergers so you're almost certainly right. However, sometimes admin deletes the subsequent comments to help avoid confusion but sometimes they're just kept as obviously it's a lot of time/effort for admin to read through them for very little benefit.