Amyfantastic's profile has all the hallmarks of a bad punt. Presumably not when you saw it on her first day though.
Lesson learnt; go to girls with positive FB and have been on the site for more than 24 hours. Your other review looks a whole lot better. Guess what, loads of positive FB and on site for more than 24 hours!!
BTW I'm not prolific either and have only been punting for about 7 months, but this site will give you a lot of good advice when it comes to the novice punter. There is also a lot of bullshit written as well, but that's life I guess. My punting success comes from finding a good regular, although others may have a different view.