Escort Scotland - Is it worth leaving reviews on UKP?

[Banquo]

Just interested chaps.. Is it worth leaving reviews for ES wg's here? I kind of gave up recently.

I've left a few reviews or mentions for ES girls, but the site seems to have such poor control over authenticity of girls profiles, pictures and reviews that I'm at the point of not bothering anymore.

The reason for the post is that I've reviewed some girls here when their photos are accurate, only to see new photos appear of a completely different girl in a few weeks - effectively a profile swap.

We all know the failings of AW with regard to feedback, but I have to admit, I think that AW manages fake profiles better than ES. I leave ES reviews here then see a few weeks/months later a completely different girl using the ES profile that I reviewed. I always list caveats when reviewing ES girls - but given the site is so poor in terms of quality control... what's the point?

Any thoughts?

[hornysixtynine]

Wow, if thats really the case and happened on more than a couple of occasions then possibly no point.

I trust certain punters on here and it could be problematic arriving at a verified wg flat to find its a munter romanian with no personal skills.

Not a fan of ES but if a review was good from a trusted member here then I'd take a punt... not now of course

[RandyF]

The two sites aren't comparable.

ES, is a shite paid advert site.  If you pay the fee, you or your granny can put a profile up.

External Link/Members Only

[Johny Stone]

External Link/Members Only
Interesting. ES owners moved the bussines to Spain recently to avoid paying tax here. Cunts.

[seeker]

E.S are a bunch if Cunts
I put a negative review up on their board in the early years
And they banned me from leaving reviews.
The prossie is there paymaster so she is ALWAYS right  .

[jambogaz]

Maybe consider if leaving a review, download a picture from their profile then upload it into the review, that way folk can see if the same girl is advertising in the "new" profile?

Would that work?  Definitely worth reviewing these girls, quite a number are on AW too.

[Titan]

Talking about profile swaps.  External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

Porn Adelle's front page photos are a different girl from the verification photo and gallery, viz. tattoo on left leg.

[hornysixtynine]

Maybe consider if leaving a review, download a picture from their profile then upload it into the review, that way folk can see if the same girl is advertising in the "new" profile?

Would that work?  Definitely worth reviewing these girls, quite a number are on AW too.

Spot on

[Banquo]

Talking about profile swaps.  External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

Porn Adelle's front page photos are a different girl from the verification photo and gallery, viz. tattoo on left leg.

That's one of the four or five ES Dundee profiles that prompted the original post. However, AW is being abused just as badly as ES in this case. This is the girl I saw : External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only , mentioned here: https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=25873.msg579930#msg579930
The verfication pic on the Porn Adelle profile belongs to rudolfina. Therefore the current Porn Adelle profile is an abuse of the verification process.

I think the idea of posting up a pic is a good one - although I'll have to practice that as it currently takes me ages. I also saw a thread in one of the southern sections where someone somehow gave away their personal details by posting a pic - I'll need to look into that.

I'm kind of torn about how to proceed. I don't want UKP to be a site that only reviews stable longstanding AW profiles - how boring would that get? There would also be very, very few reviews for Dundee or Aberden.

In the past I've dropped "mini reviews" into the Dundee thread, mostly because I feel the information given is only valid for a very short time and therefore doesn't warrant a review. This came after having to add comments to reviews saying "the pics on this profile are no longer of the girl I saw"

ES is undoubtedly worse than AW for these profile swaps and abuses though.