Think of punting like learning to ride a bike: when you're starting out any sturdy old thing will do, it's only once you know what you're doing that you'll be able to appreciate quality.
Of course give yourself good odds going in by doing some research and playing it safe with a well-reviewed SP. But don't hold out for a unicorn. Accept that your first punt will be completely out of your comfort zone, you'll probably make some rookie mistake or faux pas, and the meet is unlikely to play out how you've carefully choreographed it in your head.
Go in with a reconnaissance mindset, learn what you can, and have fun!