Just as an aside........I have never understood that phrase(ology)
Sean Lock died and I just knew someone would come out with it,
"He was the comedians comedian"
It means he was a comedian that lots of other comedians liked.
It shows that the artist in question has a firm grip of their art to the extent where other artists/entertainers appreciate them as well as us ignorant plebs.
Im trying to think of a counter, a successful act who isn’t really liked by their peers. It’s still early and I haven’t had my second cup of tea yet, so all I can really think of is the band Nickelback. They they’ve sold a lot of records, but don’t really have the respect of other musicians.
Edit: 2nd cup of tea kicked in and just thought of an other one.
Jack Vettriano. Scottish painter who’s had huge commercial success, but is really looked down upon by other artists and the art establishment.