I mean, I have to give kudos to her for remembering the op after three years and inbetween the 100s of men she would have fucked.
I can see both points of whether this should be negative or not, but I think the question is whether her reasoning with the review was fair or not as that was the reason for refusal. I would get it if the old review was negative, or reflected services that were not true, but it seems to me it was reflecting the ops positive experience. Maybe she didnt like the sex, but that wasnt the reason of refusal.
I would also ask the op whether he was using the same number as he did three years ago, because if she didnt want to timewaste she should have just blocked his number.