Intriguingly my condemnatory view proved to be correct. 
No, it wasn't. I was speaking of your condemnatory view of the OP's request for advice, despite a complete lack of previous contributions - not the girl. It was plainly obvious she'd turn out to be a narcissistic, miserable bastard, as I said so myself at the time.
And even if you were referring to the OP, nobody went after him denying him information - quite the opposite in fact. Only you came anywhere close.