If you are new to punting as well as new to Fife, I would seriously caution you against punting with anyone in Fife (except Beth, if she becomes available again soon). I can tell you from many years of experience that finding a good punt in fife is like finding a needle in the world's largest haystack. If you just pick someone from AW based on their review score there is a 99% chance you will be sorely disappointed, and possibly put off punting for life. Same goes for Dundee, so don't just hop on a train and head up there; that's just another route to disappointment.
Read the review on here and spread your wings a little bit wider. Better to spend an extra 15 quid or so on a trip to Edinburgh than throw money down the drain punting in Fife.