I agree with you on this. However, those asking for recommendations for particular days should do what the rest of us do, go out and punt. If it's shit THEN TELL US. If it's amazing THEN TELL US. I am more than happy to help the fellow punter, but sometimes you have to put in the hard work yourself and sort the wheat from the chaff.
I agree, some of my best punts have been from recommendations on here.
Recently saw Amanda at 2 lisle street on a Thursday but was disappointed, she was well described and quite friendly but I thought she was quite jaded and just going through the motions. This could have just been me though, I really don't like this venue and the lighting is very dark which makes it feel like a fumble in the dark !
Also recently visited Nicky at 18 Newport Court on a Friday, it was quite late, about 8.30 and 34 Romilly St had already shut so was not expecting anything amazing but was pleasently surprised, she is well described tall, curvy with long dark hair and lovely tanned and smooth skin, natural boobs larger than you would expect on her frame. Enthusiastic and friendly service very chatty afterwards as I got dressed to the point where I almost wanted to pay for another session
Recommended and I will definitely be returning