Chardonnay.
I saw her earlier this year, haven't seen brooke so can't comment on her.
Chardonnay's got a bag full of positive reviews so you know 100% what you'll get with her.
What I will say is her body is honestly a LOT better than how she looks in her photos. I think her photos are way too photoshopped which always leaves you skeptical in her looks department. I can confirm her body is out of this world.
Her face is about 6 or 7/10 but overall she delivers solid GFE. I think I may go back and try out her B2B massage!