How old would you say she is Billy?
I'll bring two reasons for my scepticism.
1. When I saw her, her face was lined and drawn so could only estimate her to have the same look as women I know of my own age, in the face and neck and I'm not mid 30' (mid 30's 34 -36).
2. I was with a girl in Sheffield around 2012 who was a proper little talker, she had worked with a girl who at the time I was seeing, earlier in her career. The girl I was seeing was 18 when she worked with her and she mentioned Cathy as the 'older experienced girl', at said brothel. No the girl I was seeing was in her low 30's at the time 2012 so she'll be 37ish now which to my reckoning must make Cathy early 40's now given that she'd have been around 21-22 when we talked about her.
Long winded I know and not an exact science but my conclusion. If you talk to any old school punters around her I mean from the turn of the century, Cathy has been around since then, and was well known.
I just find it incredible that given her location which is gopping her looks which are to be kind extremely plain, all you can give is an OK, service and a not bad body , yet so many positives and then so much controversy.