Well that's a question you have to ask yourself. I've reviewed girls that no one has seen as well, and I kind of got a bit of comments about being a bit flowery for one of them elsewhere but I didn't get called out for being fluffy. I've also been called out for "wasting my money" on long bookings and chatting. But that's just the way I like it and I don't really have to adhere to their standard for my personal enjoyment. 50% of the people responding to your posts on this site will probably go against you and the rest 50% with you, that won't change ever and you just have to get used to it....unless you are someone like NigelF.
With that said, you only got shit for one review (i.e. the latest one) and that is very tame in all honesty. But I'll explain what the issue with that particular review was as best as possible. It was the overt fluffiness with cliche use of words (I'll explain why this is exactly an issue in a bit), now bear in mind that is all fine if you felt that way and she blew your socks off. Many of us probably do feel that way from time to time with someone and anyone who says otherwise is a straight up liar. However, those details are not actually important to a review and it just causes the reader to cringe because there have been reviews where the reviewer would use those same exact cliche phrases and then someone else would go see the girl and find out that she's a shit provider and the reviewer was just so enamoured by her that he didn't see it. That is the reason why that kind of stuff is frowned upon, even if she genuinely is that good. It's because it becomes difficult to tell if you are being objective about the important things.
It was also on the long end, but they convey less information than a lot of other shorter reviews. It's not really important to talk about how many fingers you put inside her vagina, or minute by minute description of the meeting. That only leads to people skimming on your reviews and focusing on the cliche lines like "Treat her well".
You are bound to get a few shit here and there every time you review someone or even post, there are just so many people here from varying age group, demographic, preference that it's just impossible to have something that pleases everyone and you just kind of have to get used to that fact. There is no need to respond to everyone who speaks out against you and defend yourself, because if you do you'll be here all day long wasting your time.