And despite my cool reaction on this one I also want to thank you as one punter to another for your other suggestions which I think have generally been innovative and very useful.
Punther, My key point is that *reviews* are picked up and linked in the list at the bottom of a post which quotes her AW number, where other posts will not be. Personally I think looks, location and communications are legitimate subject for commentary and rating in a review. If you turn up and she is sufficiently unattractive you don't want to proceed other punters would like to know this, same if you felt threated by the location. Grade it neutral if you prefer but let us know, and do it in a review so we can find it easily.
I do agree that the review functionality and the way it links is ideal (though threads that contain an AW ID that is searched for will still show up in a search)
Re reading the rules on review I think maybe I misunderstood it
Out of curiousity though in this situation specifically what would you do?:
not long ago i aborted a punt and called the wg to cancel as there was a police car very close to the house.
As when I saw the car close to the premises in my mind I was thinking maybe this is a stakeout on the house hence why I did not proceed and called to cancel.
I had not met her, could not say she if she was a B+S, had a poor attitude, backed out of agreed services, poor comms/ no response on arrival etc etc. - Basically the things that we would all say requires a formal review
What exactly would I say I was reviewing as I could not really say anything about the girl at that point
In your opinion would you say this still holds true? From the rules for reviews:
A new review thread can only be created once a service provider has agreed to a booking (e.g. verbally or by textual messaging). A meet does not need to take place, money does not need change hands, the only requirement is that the she had accepted the initial booking.
Only one review thread is permissible per punt. Do not combine multiple punts in the same review thread, neither should a single punt be split into multiple review threads. Only sex workers can be the subject of a review, not a whole agency / establishment / brothel.
Would be interesting to get admins view on this as if he say a neutral review would be the way to go about situations like this then you are right maybe there is no need for a thread like this