Safia

[superam]

External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

[Link expanded by admin]

This meeting took place before xmas and the day after her profile went offline for a fair while so didn't get round to posting it as I couldn't post a link in.
I wont go into a full TNS break down of proceedings has Safia has been reviewed quite afew times before on here but would just like to add my ten penath worth.
I found her to be the most accommadating girl I have seen to date, she gave the impression of being a little nervous herself (good acting or new punter, who knows) but was up for direction all the way as to what I required instead of some of the military action you get from some/most girls. I wasn't rushed in the slightest, despite having 2 or 3 times up knocks at the door 'don't worry, carry on' was the call which I thought was a nice touch. Throughly enjoyable young lady to spend some time with and I must say i'm rather embarrassed to say I haven't returned yet, that will be put right soon enough hopefully.

[CoolTiger]

Good to see Safia get another postive review on here, my current favourite Indian girl.

SR, you need to post BOTH of the AW links, in order for the review system to pick up her reviews. Have asked Admin to amend the link.

External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

[TheNewSeeker]

Cheers, she's one of my top targets - but hard to get hold of.

Note she had a now defunct profile to which a couple of reviews are linked:

External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

These will be linked to below

[CoolTiger]

Cheers, she's one of my top targets - but hard to get hold of.

Note she had a now defunct profile to which a couple of reviews are linked:

External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

These will be linked to below

Indeed. Steely Dan picked this up and has included her old profile reviews in the list of E M Escorts.

[Steely Dan]

Thanks for trying to write a review.  You may get cross with me now. Let me give you the same old boring speech I give every one - the least important thing is the rating.  What is important to other punters is why.  If I remove everything that is fluff, here is what is left:

Blah blah about AW. I found her to be accommodating. She seemed nervous but took direction.  I wasn't rushed. There were knocks at the door . Enjoyable. Young.  I haven't returned yet.

My opinion: Please say something, or don't write a review.  (Can you say 'we had sex' if you did?)

Here are some things that others like to include:

-Booking and communication.
-Price.
-Services taken by Punter compared to those offered by WG (No porn script needed, but say something or don't bother posting at all).
-WG - a) Looks / body / hygiene b) Enthusiasm throughout c) Personality d) Accuracy of profile and in particular photos.
-Incall location - clean & tidy, comfortable, shower or not.

(there is much more advice on the Wiki - this is the TL/DR)

It is not my opinion that matters, only Admin can make the call, but this to me is a rating without a review attached. I see no mention of any of the above items. (Ok to be fair, you describe her personality as accommodating, but I don't really know what that means.  Same for Young. Is she 17? One hopes not.) She does not have many reviews - it would be pretty easy to add to our knowledge.  But whether well reviewed or not, every review can be helpful. This one not so much.

I do not mean to slam you. We all want you to write reviews.  But I am sorry in my opinion, this is not one.

[superam]

Steely Dan, you are entitled to your opinion like everyone else my friend, doesn't mean you right i'm afraid and in my eyes, on this occasion your not. I accept the info given is brief but I did qualify that right at the start of the review (or non review as you see it) 
This is a sort of review I like to read sometimes, something less clinical and i'm quite sure there are plenty on here that have got positive thoughts from said review, which in my mind makes it well worth posting. 

[Iloveoral]

Hey SR, nice one matey, I totally agree with what you wrote, I found her a little nervous at the start to but in fairness so was I, she's a stunning girl, does everything you ask and in my opinion you probably don't need to list position by position, after so many reviews of her, as yourself I've not been back to see her but also plan to correct that very soon.

[Timmy2]

Am I missing something here....a few of you have mentioned numerous reviews...I can only see three...

Discuss

Raddy

[GolfNut]

Steely Dan, you are entitled to your opinion like everyone else my friend, doesn't mean you right i'm afraid and in my eyes, on this occasion your not. I accept the info given is brief but I did qualify that right at the start of the review (or non review as you see it) 
This is a sort of review I like to read sometimes, something less clinical and i'm quite sure there are plenty on here that have got positive thoughts from said review, which in my mind makes it well worth posting. 

I'm with SD on this one matey. If a girl has dozens of reviews on here then a less concise report can indeed be justified.
But there is an absolute lack of any useful information. I wouldn't even call it a review personally.

You stated that she has plenty of reviews on here but your review only links to one other. CT posted the link for her old profile which links to 2 more, but still not many or enough if she is as good as you say she is.

She's still a pretty unknown quantity therefore, so a more detailed report would have been much more helpful than a few lines. What you have described wouldn't be sufficient info for me to make a call on whether or not to book her, so for me your review is worthless. Sorry to be blunt but that's how I see it.

[CoolTiger]

Am I missing something here....a few of you have mentioned numerous reviews...I can only see three...

Discuss

Raddy

She was having trouble with an EAS Punter and deleted her profile. She now has a new one.

In the list of E M Escorts at the top, Steely Dan has kindly linked BOTH her profiles, as there are 2/3 reviews linked to her old profile.

[CoolTiger]

I'm with SD on this one matey. If a girl has dozens of reviews on here then a less concise report can indeed be justified.
But there is an absolute lack of any useful information. I wouldn't even call it a review personally.

You stated that she has plenty of reviews on here but your review only links to one other. CT posted the link for her old profile which links to 2 more, but still not many or enough if she is as good as you say she is.

She's still a pretty unknown quantity therefore, so a more detailed report would have been much more helpful than a few lines. What you have described wouldn't be sufficient info for me to make a call on whether or not to book her, so for me your review is worthless. Sorry to be blunt but that's how I see it.

Would agree with you that 3 or 4 reviews on their own are not enough. However, there was a long thread on her where quite a few other members posted that they had seen her and would recommend
her, but never submitted a review on her (warning - long thread)....

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=39362.0

[CoolTiger]

Sorry, this is the long thread I was referring to....

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=30712.msg429327;topicseen#msg429327

[superam]

Yes CT, I was basing my 'review' on the fact she had been discussed at length on here by the East Mids crew.

[dubs]

... I wasn't rushed in the slightest, despite having 2 or 3 times up knocks at the door 'don't worry, carry on' was the call which I thought was a nice touch.

Does she work in a parlour then?

[CoolTiger]

Does she work in a parlour then?

No, it's a private flat that she she shares with another WG. If you read the long thread, the other girl's profile is mentioned in there.

[superam]

From a flat mate, always been a couple of girls there whenever I've been.
Seen Liz at same add, not sure if she works from there though, may do
External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

[GolfNut]

Yes CT, I was basing my 'review' on the fact she had been discussed at length on here by the East Mids crew.

 

Not really the idea that to get info you've got to read through pages and pages of discussion.

The idea is that a review is posted to tell us what she is like. Certainly for the benefit of those that haven't read or couldn't be bothered to wade through a convoluted thread like the two in question.

[CoolTiger]

From a flat mate, always been a couple of girls there whenever I've been.
Seen Liz at same add, not sure if she works from there though, may do
External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

Have not seen Liz. There used to be a cracking Brazilian girl working from the same flat. Never got to see her.

[Iloveoral]

I've met and reviewed her and I'll also stand my my statement she is the best punt I've had to date, for services, looks, effort and comms I had absolutely no issues for once.

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=74200.0

I've tried a few times to get a short notice booking but she isn't always available, but she always texts me back to apologies and explain.

She isn't polish and she isn't at a polish club lol you park near there and walk into a nearby housing estate.

I though on this occasion SR gave a fair review of his event without going into every detail but confirmed it was inline with other reviews, he's new don't  flame the guy hehe

[Timmy2]

Not really the idea that to get info you've got to read through pages and pages of discussion.

The idea is that a review is posted to tell us what she is like. Certainly for the benefit of those that haven't read or couldn't be bothered to wade through a convoluted thread like the two in question.

Was about to say the same thing....reviews are how we judge if a girl is worth seeing or not. No need to do a Raddy or MOTC review but more than your review to be fair
Raddy

[Iloveoral]

From a flat mate, always been a couple of girls there whenever I've been.
Seen Liz at same add, not sure if she works from there though, may do
External Link/Members Only or External Link/Members Only

Liz looks nice

[CoolTiger]

Was about to say the same thing....reviews are how we judge if a girl is worth seeing or not. No need to do a Raddy or MOTC review but more than your review to be fair
Raddy

MOST of us East Mids members could never be in your league 

[superam]

Liz looks nice

Liz is/was nice mate, started seeing her must be 4/5 years ago now, not sure how it's all hanging now though, them photo's are the sames one's she started with. She also has some discussion about her, needless to say give your number out at your peril, she will send you numerous messages of offers and pleads to meet up, some that suits, some it don't.

[splodger69]

Watch out for Liz, she is one of those WGs that keeps your phone number... best use a punter phone lols

Liz looks nice

[CoolTiger]

Liz is/was nice mate, started seeing her must be 4/5 years ago now, not sure how it's all hanging now though, them photo's are the sames one's she started with. She also has some discussion about her, needless to say give your number out at your peril, she will send you numerous messages of offers and pleads to meet up, some that suits, some it don't.

Watch out for Liz, she is one of those WGs that keeps your phone number... best use a punter phone lols

Indeed. Good advice Splodger!!

[superam]

Indeed. Good advice Splodger!!

But CT don't mind offers

[CoolTiger]

But CT don't mind offers

Indeed. I encourage WGs to store my number, and keep me informed of any "special offers" they may be running. In some weeks, I may get as many as 4/5 texts of special offers, especially if work is slow for the WG concerned.

All the more reason to have a punting phone. For years, I'ver had a basic Nokia as a punting phone, but am now thinking of getting a basic smartphone, mainly for whatsapp convo with the WGs and direct access to my punting emails.

[_Bender_]

Liz is back working as she's been in contact, and it is the same flat where Safia works from and I also was a chick called Holly there a couple of years back.

Yes the girl Brazilian Natalia worked there but I believe she's was Canadian with Brazilian heritage.

[superam]

Big tits as I remember from photo's Bender

[_Bender_]

Yeah, she had a rack on her, and she took it up the arse, shame there's no one like her in Derby 

[smiths]

Thanks for trying to write a review.  You may get cross with me now. Let me give you the same old boring speech I give every one - the least important thing is the rating.  What is important to other punters is why.  If I remove everything that is fluff, here is what is left:

My opinion: Please say something, or don't write a review.  (Can you say 'we had sex' if you did?)

Here are some things that others like to include:

-Booking and communication.
-Price.
-Services taken by Punter compared to those offered by WG (No porn script needed, but say something or don't bother posting at all).
-WG - a) Looks / body / hygiene b) Enthusiasm throughout c) Personality d) Accuracy of profile and in particular photos.
-Incall location - clean & tidy, comfortable, shower or not.

(there is much more advice on the Wiki - this is the TL/DR)

It is not my opinion that matters, only Admin can make the call, but this to me is a rating without a review attached. I see no mention of any of the above items. (Ok to be fair, you describe her personality as accommodating, but I don't really know what that means.  Same for Young. Is she 17? One hopes not.) She does not have many reviews - it would be pretty easy to add to our knowledge.  But whether well reviewed or not, every review can be helpful. This one not so much.

I do not mean to slam you. We all want you to write reviews.  But I am sorry in my opinion, this is not one.

I agree that more useful info would of been handy from the OP but at least he bothered to post something and others can ask the OP questions about the WG and punt if they wish to so to ME the OP posting this up is better than him not posting anything.

Briefly reading his previous reviews this one is a step backwards from some of them info wise though where he does give some good info so no idea why he didn't follow that format this time.

[vw]

Steely Dan, you are entitled to your opinion like everyone else my friend, doesn't mean you right i'm afraid and in my eyes, on this occasion your not. I accept the info given is brief but I did qualify that right at the start of the review (or non review as you see it) 
This is a sort of review I like to read sometimes, something less clinical and i'm quite sure there are plenty on here that have got positive thoughts from said review, which in my mind makes it well worth posting. 

Imagine admin will disagree, as he says this is UKP not Adultwork.

Glad you had a good time but information is needed or this site will turn to dog shit !

[CoolTiger]

Imagine admin will disagree, as he says this is UKP not Adultwork.

Glad you had a good time but information is needed or this site will turn to dog shit !

Admin has now now turned the review into a discussion thread and, accordingly, moved it out of the reviews section.

[GolfNut]

Admin has now now turned the review into a discussion thread and, accordingly, moved it out of the reviews section.

Good call by Admin. 

[superam]

Good call by Admin. 

I've felt compelled to come on here tonight and air my views. I understand Admin can make whatever decisions they like and that's fine. I also understand my 'review' wasn't has detailed as normal, however i'm quite surprised how this has gone tbh.
Golfnut I see you do good and useful things for this site but on this occasion you seemed to be on some sort of power trip, I've got to get my own way style point. The thread has been moved, there was no need for you to add your twopenth ' good decision by admin thumps up  PATHETIC.  Maybe it's because I was challenged what you said and you didn't like it, more likely is. If this site wants half a dozen of you only, reviewing the same girls with the same content day after day, then I reacon your going the right way about alienating people. Hope your happy with your days work THUMPS UP.

[GolfNut]

No need to throw your toys out mate.

I was making the point that the final decision was in my mind the correct one.

If you care to check I didn't report your review, vw did that and Admin made the call.

As a fairly good contributor to the site in general, I think you failed to add a review that was up to standard. Maybe good enough for AW, but not UKP. You have produced some decent reviews to date, so clearly you know how to do it. Just on this occasion you fell short of the mark. And I wasn't the first to flag it up in fact at least 4 respected members not including myself came to the same conclusion, but nobody agreed that it was a satisfactory review. Think that says it all.

Anyway absolutely no hard feelings from my end, and I'm sure business will resume as normal in the cold light of day.

Take a cup of humility and learn from the forum instead of making yourself look like a twelve year old who didn't get want he wants for Christmas.

GN 

[Owwhatanight]

I've felt compelled to come on here tonight and air my views. I understand Admin can make whatever decisions they like and that's fine. I also understand my 'review' wasn't has detailed as normal, however i'm quite surprised how this has gone tbh.
Golfnut I see you do good and useful things for this site but on this occasion you seemed to be on some sort of power trip, I've got to get my own way style point. The thread has been moved, there was no need for you to add your twopenth ' good decision by admin thumps up  PATHETIC.  Maybe it's because I was challenged what you said and you didn't like it, more likely is. If this site wants half a dozen of you only, reviewing the same girls with the same content day after day, then I reacon your going the right way about alienating people. Hope your happy with your days work THUMPS UP.

Come on Superam there's no malace here in the East Mids, we just all help each other out one way or another. There's enough shit flies our way at times or when we do get things wrong but you must have noticed we are nice group ...you included.

I do recommend you go watch Forest for a change ? Bring a smile to your face

[RedKettle]

I've felt compelled to come on here tonight and air my views. I understand Admin can make whatever decisions they like and that's fine. I also understand my 'review' wasn't has detailed as normal, however i'm quite surprised how this has gone tbh.
Golfnut I see you do good and useful things for this site but on this occasion you seemed to be on some sort of power trip, I've got to get my own way style point. The thread has been moved, there was no need for you to add your twopenth ' good decision by admin thumps up  PATHETIC.  Maybe it's because I was challenged what you said and you didn't like it, more likely is. If this site wants half a dozen of you only, reviewing the same girls with the same content day after day, then I reacon your going the right way about alienating people. Hope your happy with your days work THUMPS UP.

If it helps I had one of my reviews removed by Admin (for Mandy) as I had only written a one liner just to confirm the 20 previous reviews.  I took it on the chin and provided a new review with more detail.

[Timmy2]

I remember that one RK, and yes you did it without a song and dance
Raddy
I remember being asked to cut one of mine down from 567 pages down to 2 pages

[Timmy2]

Come on Superam there's no malace here in the East Mids, we just all help each other out one way or another. There's enough shit flies our way at times or when we do get things wrong but you must have noticed we are nice group ...you included.

I do recommend you go watch Forest for a change ? Bring a smile to your face

or Notts...... you will be as miserable as me then

[CoolTiger]

Come on Superam there's no malace here in the East Mids, we just all help each other out one way or another. There's enough shit flies our way at times or when we do get things wrong but you must have noticed we are nice group ...you included.

I do recommend you go watch Forest for a change ? Bring a smile to your face

or Notts...... you will be as miserable as me then

All of you need to step up a gear and try the big league for a change   

[GolfNut]

+1 to all the above.

What a great bunch of guys.

I apologise if the thumbs up offended you superam. Maybe was a bit uncalled for in hindsight.

Bring on your next review mate. I'm sure it'll be great!

GN 

[Timmy2]

+1 to all the above.

What a great bunch of guys.

I apologise if the thumbs up offended you superam. Maybe was a bit uncalled for in hindsight.

Bring on your next review mate. I'm sure it'll be great!

GN 

Nice one GN 

[Steely Dan]

And it is unfortunate if my original critique of your comments was upsetting.  But I am not sorry I wrote it.  This site only has value because we do challenge reviews (both positive and negative), and also comments, suggestions, recomendations and so on - from both new posters, and returning posters. If we had the attitude of trusting everyone and everything, soon there would be unhelpful rubbish posted.  When it is your post under pressure, I know how bad it can feel.  But this really is necessary.  One review here is worth a hundred on AW.  Because of this pressure.

I actually don't do that (be the 'bad guy') much - I like to stay out of conflict usually.  But I felt it was my turn this week.  If we all don't take a turn to be the 'bad guy', the site could lose what makes it good.

The guys on here have (mostly) never met.  But we have a shared hobby, and try to help each other to get it right.  And we try to have a laugh. But I will tell you the truth, I care more about good advice on which escort to fuck next than I do about having a laugh with the guys on here that I have never met.

[Owwhatanight]

And it is unfortunate if my original critique of your comments was upsetting.  But I am not sorry I wrote it.  This site only has value because we do challenge reviews (both positive and negative), and also comments, suggestions, recomendations and so on - from both new posters, and returning posters. If we had the attitude of trusting everyone and everything, soon there would be unhelpful rubbish posted.  When it is your post under pressure, I know how bad it can feel.  But this really is necessary.  One review here is worth a hundred on AW.  Because of this pressure.

I actually don't do that (be the 'bad guy') much - I like to stay out of conflict usually.  But I felt it was my turn this week.  If we all don't take a turn to be the 'bad guy', the site could lose what makes it good.

The guys on here have (mostly) never met.  But we have a shared hobby, and try to help each other to get it right.  And we try to have a laugh. But I will tell you the truth, I care more about good advice on which escort to fuck next than I do about having a laugh with the guys on here that I have never met.

  
gave me the horn that speech SD  )))

[superam]

No need to throw your toys out mate.

I was making the point that the final decision was in my mind the correct one.

If you care to check I didn't report your review, vw did that and Admin made the call.

As a fairly good contributor to the site in general, I think you failed to add a review that was up to standard. Maybe good enough for AW, but not UKP. You have produced some decent reviews to date, so clearly you know how to do it. Just on this occasion you fell short of the mark. And I wasn't the first to flag it up in fact at least 4 respected members not including myself came to the same conclusion, but nobody agreed that it was a satisfactory review. Think that says it all.

Anyway absolutely no hard feelings from my end, and I'm sure business will resume as normal in the cold light of day.

Take a cup of humility and learn from the forum instead of making yourself look like a twelve year old who didn't get want he wants for Christmas.

GN 

Yeah fair comments but then you have to go spoil yourself with the last line, got to have the last word comes to mind.

[GolfNut]

Yeah fair comments but then you have to go spoil yourself with the last line, got to have the last word comes to mind.

Fella. If you read my last post, it says I'm happy to leave it at that, and actually apologised for the thumbs up.

Your response to my original thread was extremely childish and if you recall you called me "Pathetic".

Under the circumstances I have actually acted in a very restrained manner and definitely do not take kindly to such remarks.

You've been on this site far longer than I have and should therefore know exactly what standard of review writing is acceptable. It's not as if you've just joined and don't know the ropes.

In those 2 and a half years you've posted 100 times and written 4 reviews. So if you think this site would rather have more people like you then I need say no more.

Like I said happy to leave it at that but please don't try and wind me up any further. That wouldn't be good for you really.

[superam]

Fella. If you read my last post, it says I'm happy to leave it at that, and actually apologised for the thumbs up.

Your response to my original thread was extremely childish and if you recall you called me "Pathetic".

Under the circumstances I have actually acted in a very restrained manner and definitely do not take kindly to such remarks.

You've been on this site far longer than I have and should therefore know exactly what standard of review writing is acceptable. It's not as if you've just joined and don't know the ropes.

In those 2 and a half years you've posted 100 times and written 4 reviews. So if you think this site would rather have more people like you then I need say no more.

Like I said happy to leave it at that but please don't try and wind me up any further. That wouldn't be good for you really.

And what does that mean?? Last line again I see

[RedKettle]

Superam

Learn when to stop!!! 

[superam]

Superam

Learn when to stop!!! 

Hold on Kettle, it's not me having last line jibes.