Popular media on UKEscorting.com

Author Topic: Star rating for reviews  (Read 608 times)

That sums it up nicely, just read the review and decide if she's got you or not.

That's exactly how I took things with the girl I saw last week.

tcm

Offline helmsdale

I think an 'Excellent' or some such category would be helpful but on the other hand if a provider is really excellent, then they will quickly clock up a number of positive reviews and that is better indication of excellence than the opinion of one poster.

In time though there will probably be rating inflation, 'excellent' will come to mean 'positive' and 'positive' will come to mean 'neutral'. so all in all its better to keep things the way they are.

Banning reason: Making race postings after being barred from Off-Topic section for racist comments. Used up all chances.

I think an 'Excellent' or some such category would be helpful but on the other hand if a provider is really excellent, then they will quickly clock up a number of positive reviews and that is better indication of excellence than the opinion of one poster.

In time though there will probably be rating inflation, 'excellent' will come to mean 'positive' and 'positive' will come to mean 'neutral'. so all in all its better to keep things the way they are.
Excellent is not one man's call though, Excellence is recognised by a pattern of reviews. 

One punter alone cannot declare excellence in my opinion.

Excellent is not one man's call though, Excellence is recognised by a pattern of reviews. 

One punter alone cannot declare excellence in my opinion.

Completely agree with that....we all want different things....who am I to say that my "excellent" punt would be "excellent" to you?

IMO the positive/neutral/negative option is enough, it enables you to give other people a rough idea of your general view of the punt and a full on rating system would just end up getting skewed as people rate and review in different styles.

For me, you can only get maximum value out of this site if you take the time to read other peoples reviews and take from them what is important to you. If people want marks out of ten, then with respect, they are probably on the wrong site.

Reviews are far too subjective, and will always be so, to merit anything more than the + N - ratings we do now.

Far more important is for reviewers to say what was requested, what was received, and how good was the delivery, as well as other indicators such as attitude, hygiene, ease of communication etc.

Totally agree. A star system is unnecessary.
It could end up like Northern Angels where every review was ten stars.
When I asked them what was the point of a review system if only ten star reviews were allowed I was banned. :rolleyes:
Cute!  :rolleyes:

Online RedKettle

Really no point to this - current system works pretty well and as someone says above often you can get what you need from the comments made.  The ratio of positive reviews to  others is a better guide than stars

Offline GreyDave

Really no point to this - current system works pretty well and as someone says above often you can get what you need from the comments made.  The ratio of positive reviews to  others is a better guide than stars

+ Meee :hi:  some times I shag girls reveiwed here as negs I do not reveiw all I have shagged ofte they have been well reveiwed and I cant add  to it I am well sus of the 10 star girls and the fluffy brigade that follow them just my 2p worth  ...did two walkups no point in reveiwing as they will more than likely be long gone next week as is the way :cool: :cool: attudie to age types is what I look for in the reveiws  :drinks:


Latest media on UKEscorting.com