personally, having read the discussion about her, she would have at best went to the bottom of my hotlist but more than likely I'd have crossed her off altogether.
Like I mentioned in the review thread itself she was actually totally crossed off my to see list on reading the negative. This was until she came onto the forum and gave the reply she did in that negative review. Which I really liked what she said. I then seen the punter never came back to challenge what she said at all so I made an internal decision that I believed her side on that issue.
So it was actually that negative review, or more specifically the way she handled it, was what made me want to see her more than I already had been.
In my opinion when a girl comes onto the forums and gives a good reply to criticism. Like Zara did, and like LilyD did. It actually makes me personally really want to see them. It just humanizes that girl and makes her more attractive/interesting to me than just a name and some stats on an agency website. I would have booked LilyD back in February but she suddenly said "no more bookings from people who haven't seen me before as a response to her negative review.
To also add this review has been my first review since last October (so first one in six months). So its not like I am "Mr put right the negative reviews" guy.