I don't think it would be useful. Punting is such a personal thing. We each have different needs and interests.
A well-argued case Puntico, I can’t deny that. I also agree with much of what you wrote.
However, I think it’s largely applicable to existing / established members who have taken the time to register and participate. Yes, they are the lifeblood of the site, but to ensure continuity and expansion of the community, one key thing is most important: fresh blood.
Virtually every single day there are multiple new folks making their first (and often last) post to elicit suggestions or recommendations from the established membership.
Wouldn’t an auto-generated ‘best seller list’ to use your analogy, be a good starting point for those new arrivals?
We all want to make the ‘right’ choices and discover the best girls who provide a good range of services at the fairest prices in any given area. For example, I’ve always been tempted to spend a week in Essex to explore the local MILF talent, but I wouldn’t know where to start.
At least that ‘best seller’ list would give me some pointers so that – worst way – I might not have a brilliant punt, but at the very least any girl who makes it to double-digit positive reviews and earns a place on the ‘top’ list is highly likely to be a safe
choice for a punt and a punters hard-earned cash.
Moreover, as some have already mentioned, given the scrutiny that both new members and new reviews (rightly) attract, I think the lists might even help
to draw out the touts, fluffies and desperate/bad service providers.