The detailed reviews actually work well for me. Just because someone eulogises about a particular WG, I tend to read between the lines and hot list them based on my own preferences, although I understand what you mean.
Adele4u Very popular and she seems to be consistent with the GFE/PSE she offers and is bisexual, so there is potential to try other things another time. I would book in advance for her.
However,
Platinum Cindy Another forum favourite, she sounds like another whom offers an excellent service similar to Adele4u, and is VFM, but, I would personally choose others first as her look isn't quite for me nowadays.
Little Katie A lot written about LK, and one I want to try and book in 2015. Booking her is a gamble at the moment, but when that gets sorted, no problem. Services and potential sound excellent. Would book ahead and wait for her.
I suppose the punting experience differs for each of us, including the booking process. I like to prepare and am able to wait up to 2 weeks or so for the booking, but have booked on the same day and enjoyed that too.