A quick look at his profile shows he's been here 3 months or so.
A quick look at yours shows around 6 months before your first review.
Just saying like. 
What has that got to do with anything?

He's commenting on the comment made not on reviews.
Look at the stats for the SP, 52 positives, 5 neutral and 3 negatives. The last negative was in November 2022 and there was no mention in that about her smelling of smoke, she got a neutral in January of this year, again no mention of smoke in fact I've never seen any mention of smoke in any reviews.
60 punters who have posted reviews don't mention smoke, 1 member who has just joined does, on the balance of probability I know which I believe.