If someone is fat or not isn't usually that subjective an issue really, whether they are attractive is more so. Now a photo from July provides some evidence that she was of course but the more recent clothed versions can't change opinions too much, as people have commented they are at different angles etc.
If Iver thinks she isn't fat now and is a size 14, that is fine - he was there not me. Would I book on the strength of that? No, I would need a secondary source and/or new photography. That isn't calling the review in to question, just the usual checks and balances I would want to make, knowing what I know now.
I have seen fat girls that carry it really well and I've wanted to bang the arse off them and others that have done absolutely nothing for me, where I would've needed a splint. Hence my first point, fat probably isn't subject just the attractiveness.