anything we suggest is administration intensive, you have to post them here, because you just don't know which of them will be prolonged in use, vs hidden fast, i personally think the profiles aren't being closed, i think they are activating, verifying and then hiding them, for later recycling as an established profile, where they may have activated it for the time it takes to create booking requests, confirm and leave feedback then disable it again.
the only real solution i see is a "dead profile" thread, where a report button could be created to auto move a post to the dead thread, but that involves work.
As it stands, does anyone browse this thread, i see notifications of new replies but don't have to do anything really, i would suspect 90% of the visitors to this thread arrive here via searching AW name or profile id number, and the size of the thread matters not to the search engine.
The screen shots are of more use, because it shows the pictures used, and then you have that reference if they appear later on a different profile