I popped my anal cherry with a girl at Sandys Superstars and it felt exquisite, not just because of her sweet, tight bumhole but because of the illicit and forbidden nature of going in through the out door . As I finished and was carefully extricating myself, she matter-of-factly exclaimed, “It’s not as messy as you would think is it?”. What could I reply to that? “No, I thought it would be covered in shit” or “My word, it’s so clean I could eat my dinner off it”. I was lost for words.
I've seen other girls who have offered anal and sometimes there is a bit of a whiff.