Seriously this is your first post and of all the things you could contribute you come out with that. Given Lucy has been long gone im dying to know your reasoning for ressurecting this post.
Are you taking the piss??? you joined in 2012 yet you've only posted 2 reviews but you are calling out a new member.
For your's and other's information being his first post it had to be approved by a mod and it seemed a reasonable question that was relevant to the topic even if it is an old thread.
You and grandaddybadman need to wind your necks in a bit and remember we are trying to give new members help encouragement and guidance not put them off posting.
As a longstanding member who has predominately leeched off the site for 10 years, if you think he had asked his question in the wrong place would it not have been more helpful to guide him to where it should have been posted.
tintin, your first post was asking for recommendation for WS - no grief just helpful answers. Any reason this new member shouldn't be treated the same.
Edit
Kev beat me to it but my points still stand.
