I previously asked Scouting to confer with MODS, and to clarify the moving of the review to discussions was correct on the basis of rule 4
IMO, Scoutings reply covered his actions, and i thank him for his reply
Like he said, he was following a directive that had come down from admin and mods regarding this, and that he had acted on that directive, and he then conveyed this to us, also adding that he too believed that there was some ambiguities surrounding this
I see that one of the MODS has his own thoughts/concerns over girls not giving their names, which is a pretty scary thought, and one what i wouldnt want to be faced with, and TBH we have seen many examples of this in recent times, with all the raids and things
Though my own thoughts regarding girls refusals to name herself, would be more down to her own personal discretion, maybe she is/was pretty new and hadnt thought about creating an alias for herself, on the flip side, if she cannot be identified by a name then she is unlikely to be outed on the net
My personal views regarding names on reviews is quite simple, I believe that names are integral to reviews and i believe this for many reasons, and that names should be included, though i can also see why rule 4 appeared to give massage shops an exemption on the providers names
From my own POV, i try to keep track of the girls i see or have seen, looking at their movements and their name changes, especially when or if they move venues
I know that some girls may work in different shops in the same town or city and will often use a different name when changing venues, sometimes this is because the new venue may already have a girl with the same name in situ and getting updates on their name changes helps us all
I know that some girls when flitting to a different shop in the same town, like to make it look like they are not taking customers from shop A to shop B, obviously not wanting to incurr the wrath of mamasans which may prevent their return in the future, so IMO, getting the girls names is paramount
A few examples of this would be say, Jojo, the Ubon girl, Jojo as worked in many shops and has also toured over a number of years, Jojo also uses the name Mintra, and occasionally jenny, in the past she as used Dear and Dara
Ploy the former Yonlanda girl i believe used Kanya at Hua Hin in Hudds but changed to Ploy in Yonlanda, as to not offend Shirley, but when she went to Sheffield, to Muang, she used the name Honey, which is the name she used in Nuneaton
Another Yonlanda girl, Nancy, Nancy originally used the name Emmy Thai then went on to promote herself as Thai magic hands, the Magic hands by Nancy, Natty Thai was another name she used too
As Emmy Thai, Nancy earned herself a bad rep, then pulled it back as Magic hands, then as Nancy and as Natty before returning to Nancy, it was only by naming her on reviews that we were able to pin her to previous names, which looking at her current bad rep proved to be the right thing to do
Another example, in fact this is a good example of why getting a girls name is important, for both good and bad reasons too
The good being related to her being popular when she first arrived in West yorks, great service, enthusiastic and good pricing, and the punters flocked to her, this did cause issue in Suhep, as the other girls were not happy with how popular she was and with her low pricing for extras
The bad relates to when she was outed for, (as reported by a UKP member on here), blatantly going BB with him, something which if i recall was backed up by a second outing, and without her name/s then we would not be able to avoid
This girl would be Lisa whom initially worked Suhep and Siriporn as Lisa, she also worked as Lisa at Hansa, though when she first went to Hansa she was using the name Rose, and a different name again when she worked Time in Bradford
And by knowing the names she uses, punters can avoid when she is in other areas, for instance, Lisa used the name Ging in Newcastle and Yaya in Radarran in Manchester, im unsure of the names she used in Chilli, which then became Chanya in M11 area, where she also worked
So like i say, i do believe that names should be included in reviews, but i also know that girls do not always want to give their name, and with what we are seeing in some of the shops now regarding their reaction to reviews, i.e the Chinese place in Bentley' then i can see getting names, or genuine names, becoming harder, which could see massage shop reviews dry up
So again, from my POV, not wishing to see shop reviews dry up, and on the basis of what rule 4 states, “ The exceptions are sex parties, duos, etc. and massage establishments where providers do not have names”, then i do have to disagree with the decision to not allow massage shop reviews without the providers name
BUT i am not the boss and im sure he/they will get rule 4 amended when they can, if they feel the need
So other than concerns over massage shop reviews drying up, im sure that once rule 4 as been amended to cover this, and we are all aware of this, then IMO, we as members have no cause to grumble
