I personally had a good time with her, I also found her pretty attractive. But can totally see I'd be in the minority there.
I find all sorts of girls hot - really normal, average looking girls with no makeup and a few extra pounds to blow your socks off sexy, drop dead gorgeous women.
Not that I'm trying to justify myself, couldn't give a fuck what anyone thinks about what I like. Just to say I've learnt a lot reading reviews on UKP over the years and we all have our own different tastes, pretty interesting to see what people like.
Shame her service seems to have gone down hill.