So are the peeps watching it too shy to fess up?
I’m going to admit I flicked through some of it on catch up.
I found the black teacher with the fat lady quite sexy and also the black contestant towards the end.
I’m thinking, if I’m generous, the judges must put a high value on ‘showmanship’ — if I’m polite — or rather gave the dwarf and the camp gay guy with big teeth extra marks for diversity (as their dancing was unimpressive). On the other hand, the fat lady really pleasantly surprised me showing yes, fat people can dance.
I don’t see why gays should get special leeway. Dwarfism is different — you could see her proportions are challenging (short stubby legs don’t have the same freedom of movement).
But the star was the fat lady. — And also the judge who said to someone, “When you come on, we don’t know your routine. It turns out you didn’t either!”
I watch it on catch-up, fast-forwarding through everything except the dances, and the judging. I like to try and anticipate the score that each judge is about to give. I know nothing about dancing, so my score-guess is based on what the judges have said.
I find the judges tend to give most marks for technique, not showmanship, which is why some impressive dances get lower marks than I would have thought based on how much I enjoyed it. Often the judges comment about poor footwork, poor posture, etc. but gave praise for giving a good show in order to end on a positive, but such dances tend to get low marks. Conversely, dances that are dull can get higher than anticipated marks if the technique was good. The judges know that the public will mainly vote based on how impressive and emotionally-charged a dance is, so tend to compensate by marking heavily on technique (like whether the dancer is leading on the correct bit of the foot for that dance, things which I don't notice).
The fat lady's dance wasn't as leaden as I thought it would be, but it wasn't very inspiring, and I certainly didn't think her the star of the show by any means. Unless she can put more passion into it, I doubt she will last very long. Whereas the fat bloke's dance was far more impressive, but he will need to do something with his hair or he will take someone's eye out. I was impressed that the camp gay guy had the confidence to begin his very first dance unaccompanied, and he certainly put plenty of passion into it. I don't recall the judges complaining too much about his technique, either, so wasn't too surprised by his marks.