Sorry for being a cynical bastard, OP, but I don't believe you. You might be touting, you might be trolling, you might be genuine, but it doesn't add up for me. More than happy to be proved wrong and to issue an apology.
Within a day and a half of your first post here, you finally go and see someone after 8 years of searching, and follow up with a fluffy review. Really?
You personally admit you have zero exerience of SPs but are happy to give advice on how to approach her, talk about value for money and make a strong recommendation?
You say this above
but then say this in your review
I don't get what you're accusing me of exactly? That I didn't see the working girl or that I lied about the fact that I'm inexperienced? Or maybe she told me to write a positive review for her and I'm in fact an irl friend? Sounds like you're suspicious about things just to be suspicious.
Firstly to address you initial point: UKpunting is a sight to review WGs it's not a sight to
find WGs. You find the WGs on AW. This is where I did most of my 'research' for 8 years or so. I actually checked btw, my account was made in 2010 on AW. Btw it has zero feedback on it from any WGs, because guess what, I didn't see anyone during that time. I did check UKpunting now and again during the three year period the account was active just to check reviews of girls I liked, but again never plucked up the courage to see anyone. Is it still leeching to check reviews when you actually do nothing with those reviews? If you consider that leeching, then yes I was a leech, I apologise.
In terms of giving a recommendation? I mean it's my personal opinion based on what I experienced. I can't say any more or less than that. It doesn't take an 'experienced' sexual lothario who's been with 500 women to understand when someone is a little shy and more submissive vs someone who is more confident and takes the lead. My judgement was that she's the former, maybe you can see her for yourself and disagree with me?
Regardless of whatever you may be suspicious of, which I still don't understand, ask yourself this one simple question. What is my motive to do any of these 'strange' clandestine things that you seem to be so suspicious of?