Posting reviews

[johnsheppard99]

I know we are only allowed to post one positive review per 12 months, per WG, per punter, but what about a positive and a neutral?
Saw a girl last month twice, first time was a positive (just) but second time 2 weeks later was a neutral raiting meet. Can I leave two, or should I put both meets into one review or something?
Its very unusual for me to meet the same girl more than once when travelling, and so close together, so not had opportunity to do two on the same person before.

[RedKettle]

The rules are clear that the only one review in 12 months only applies to two positives, so yes.

[johnsheppard99]

The rules are clear that the only one review in 12 months only applies to two positives, so yes.

I was trying to find a FAQ/rules list to check but had no luck, cheers.

[Hurley]

Tag the second one on to the first one

[Blackpool Rock]

I know we are only allowed to post one positive review per 12 months, per WG, per punter, but what about a positive and a neutral?
Saw a girl last month twice, first time was a positive (just) but second time 2 weeks later was a neutral raiting meet. Can I leave two, or should I put both meets into one review or something?
Its very unusual for me to meet the same girl more than once when travelling, and so close together, so not had opportunity to do two on the same person before.

If you want the site rules then scroll down to the very bottom of the main page and that's where the link is in very small writing, TBH it would probably be a good idea to make the link a bit more prominent as it's easy to miss.

On the basis you haven't actually reviewed the girl yet at all then IMO it would seem strange if you posted 2 reviews and i'd combine them into one overall review and score accordingly, your call but a borderline positive and a neutral looks more like 1 overall neutral

[mh]

Tag the second one on to the first one

That wouldn't give a true picture if they had different ratings.

[daviemac]

I was trying to find a FAQ/rules list to check but had no luck, cheers.

At the bottom of the page.      https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=1.0

The relevant part -

- Reviews

* A new review thread can only be created once a service provider has agreed to a booking (e.g. verbally or by textual messaging). A meet does not need to take place, money does not need change hands, the only requirement is that the service provider had accepted the initial booking.
* Only one positive review thread can be posted for a service provider by one member per 12 month period, the exception is if the new positive review is for a threesome (or more) booking. This 12-month restriction only applies to positive reviews, not neutral or negative (they can be posted anytime after a positive review). During the 12-month period a member can add their new positive reviews to their existing review thread in the form of a reply.
* Positive reviews can only be placed in the 12 months after the punt. No time limit on negative or neutral reviews.
* Positive reviews cannot be placed for cancelled bookings.
* Only sex workers can be the subject of a review, not a whole agency / establishment / brothel. The exception is massage establishments where providers do not have names.
* Reviews must contain either a link, contact details or address (if publicised by the service provider).
* Only one review thread per punt. Do not combine multiple punts in the same review thread, neither should a same punt be split into multiple review threads. Do not post the same review in multiple regions.
* Past or current sex workers or anyone related to a sex worker (e.g. boyfriend) may not review any other sex worker.

[Happyjose]

Posting a positive and a neutral simultaneously, when the neutral is the more recent sounds a bit daft, to be honest

Personally, I would post the neutral, including mention that you had visited before and would have rated it positive at that time

[The_Don]

Even if, I have several positive punts with the same W/G over time (several years or months etc) and I wish to update a review. I may post a reply to that first review, (not starting a new one).

But I will post a new review, if some thing had changed my view and rating about punting that W/G.

Just like I did with:

Yvett

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=114160.0


Stellaa90

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=112662.0


Busty Jenny32

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=78883.0


LOVE TAYLA

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=58211.0


Busty Milf Sandra

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=54800.0

[Blackpool Rock]

Even if, I have several positive punts with the same W/G over time (several years or months etc) and I wish to update a review. I may post a reply to that first review, (not starting a new one).

But I will post a new review, if some thing had changed my view and rating about punting that W/G.

Just like I did with:

Which I think we would all agree is the right way to do it, for the 1st girl (not checked the others) your reviews are about 2 years apart so it shows a change from your original experience over time however this guy hasn't actually reviewed the girl at all when he started the thread and his punts are only 2-3 weeks apart

[The_Don]

Which I think we would all agree is the right way to do it, for the 1st girl (not checked the others) your reviews are about 2 years apart so it shows a change from your original experience over time however this guy hasn't actually reviewed the girl at all when he started the thread and his punts are only 2-3 weeks apart

I've gone from a positive (punt and review) to negative (punt and review), in a few weeks.

But for me, if I hadn't reviewed the W/G (but punted several times) and between those punts. My view and rating had changed, if and when I do review, I would post what was most relevant. i.e was positive or neutral or negative.


Which as also happened

Miss+Selfish

https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=104005.0

I was going to post a negative review. I remembered SamLP post on Redemption for cancelling

I must admit, I have a few punts that I've not reviewed and may get round to them at some point, if and when I have time.

Thanks for all the comments 

I used to be a lurker (just reading)   

I'm still a litlle lazy, in adding reviews (40% + have been added, but some may never get added  )

After all the help this forum and its members have offered me. I'm just glad that I, can contribute something back.

And with the current rules on UKP, around 12 month positive, they would be a mix of positive, neutral, negative and relevant (with in the current site rules).