Should reviews be collected under one topic

[overdone]

Just had quick look on first page of reviews for Sheffield area & see 2 thread on the first page for same person both +. But should these be grouped together so anyone wanting to see reviews on a certain girl can see them all together - if they are + or -. Also seen some other who same girl have - review on new topic on 2 different pages. So when people post reviews should they search for them? Should admin group the reviews together - or it could look odd if one escort has 5 different tpoics with + reviews on each page so everyone can see her reviews on whatever page but with a - review hidden away somewhere on the last page. Everything should be in the same topic so you can see a full overview of the girl you are thinking about spending money on. If this means some work for admin merging all them together & just saying that we just search for the girl. The only time they should appear in a different area is if a London escort goes on tour in Leeds or Birmingham (just picking 2 different areas) then they can have a review in London & West midlands area thread. But with note saying they are in London area (we do have that connect to review thing)

[OldAdmin]

Each review is an independent discussion thread. That's never going to change.

A single page for reviews (without replies) already exist in two forms:

The 'Service Provider' pages:
https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?action=serviceprovider;id=3945

Or the 'Recent Reviews' pages:
https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?action=reviews30days

[stevedave]

For AW girls, as long as the link has been provided that contains the individual WG's number, then there should be a link at the bottom of their review to all other reviews on UKP, so you can see that "Claire of Wakefield" for example has 5 other reviews on here, and can then view them all by clicking on the link.

I would presume this is a lot more difficult to do with parlour and/or agency girls though? I'm not a techie in the slightest so wouldn't know for sure!

[yorkshire123]

Personally I think the (new) way of displaying all reviews for said girl below every review was a great leap forward, this is only for AW reviews I think but more than adequate for my search needs.

May I be as bold to suggest that you start to share your punting conquests & gain at least a modicum of credibility as a punter before attempting to reengineer a free site that at this moment in time is extremely fit for purpose.

You may have also noticed my omission of the standard "with respect or no offence meant" comments, that's because they would be hollow & false   

[overdone]

That feature does make it easy when you are looking for more than 1 review & to see if anyone have - stuff, might be a certain service you are after & she's not good at that one.

[cueball]

Existing system is fine, it's not broke and don't need fixing