Guys; let's not use this conversation as an excuse to attack one another.
Rather, I'd conclude that Giac has high expectations which others, myself included, do not share. Take Your_Sexy _Katie, for example; very attractive to my eyes, though admittedly not perfect. But overall a brilliant punt. I'd certainly like to visit Bonnie despite what he has said.
I consider Giac's contribution as both honest and, to a degree, useful, although I wouldn't necessarily agree with his conclusions.
In the ultimate analysis, satisfaction in punting and one's perception of WGs contains a degree of subjectivity. So one man's erotic ideal might be another man's munter...