Completely agree - Photo shopped picture = no picture, because girls often look so different from their photo-shopped selves it might as well be a photo of someone else - 2 grades better - and because photo shopped pictures often point to bait and switch.
In a non-shopped model shoot the photographer is still paid to show a girl at her very best, which is not what I'm going to see, so it becomes a question of the degree of disappointment, which is hardly the best way to start a meet.
By contrast even a poor selfie in a cluttered room or picture in the park is more useful, because the room, clothes, pose all say something about the girl, and because you there's at least some chance she may actually look better when you meet.
Of course girls sometimes post such rubbish pictures that you might mistakenly think they're too rough to bother with, but if she's lazy enough to put up something that does her an active disservice then that says something too.