Hi SD
You'll know I have contributed to parts of the wiki where I feel qualified. I have always been slightly uneasy as there is no published editorial policy, so I have never been sure where i was treading on toes and how to respond when I disagreed with later alterations. It would be helpful to know your role; do you have an invitation or agreement with admin in this area please?
As UKP grows and becomes more sophisticated some parts of the wiki need to be updated. Without any disrespect to the attempt (I benefited too) I would also say some bits of the wiki that now look very dated were just too ambitious and don't reflect realism about our resources. Content in the wiki should be reasonably enduring, which rules out commenting on particular providers or locations for the most part in my view. This is not to say don't do it, but recognize it is going to be dated and quickly irrelevant. Personally, I would encourage an editor to erase unsustainable content when it becomes outdated.
I have no role at all. I just boldly edit when I feel like it, and post stuff here on UKP encouraging others to edit PW when I feel like it.
There is a published editorial policy. It is just refreshingly short. I am too lazy to look it up but it is something like 'Be bold. And it is all about supporting punters.'
So if any bits are outdated then go on, fix them!
I happen to disagree that commenting on particular providers or locations is a problem. And I don't think all content needs to be enduring, though it is good if it is. Because changing PW is as easy as posting here. So I do agree that when content is wrong it should be deleted or corrected right away. Five or ten more active editors and we will have it sorted. There are a few too many who post stuff and then bugger off. Still, better that than doing nothing.
So anyway, change anything you want. I (or others) might un-change a few things. But that is all good. You change 10 things. I correct 1 or 2. Maybe you change a few things I wrote. We end up with a better wiki. If we have real conflict, Admin sorts it. But that is a problem we have not had yet. So I say to all, go on, improve PuntingWiki. If it is not as good as you want it to be, it is your fault.