Forum rules on reviewing the same girl twice

[justapunter]

I have not posted any reviews yet. I have had three punts since oct. One punt was with two wgs - which I've already commented on , the 2nd punt was with one of the wgs from the two girl punt, but she was just on her own (thank fuck) . 3rd punt today and fresh in mind, balls emptied i'm in reviewing mood and want to review all three wgs . So post what I can remeber of the two girl punt back in oct, post last weeks (2nd punt) and post todays punt!

lotta of reviewing

[vw]

Post what is accurate, recent would be best as more info.

Have you read the review writing guide?

External Link/Members Only

[cueball]

You've got three reviews there op imo.

Even if it's the same lass on a couple, there's a different dynamic to each punt... mf/mff etc.

Get tapping away. Remember.... you're writing the review for US and not for her... you'll be fine then 

[vw]

You've got three reviews there op imo.

Even if it's the same lass on a couple, there's a different dynamic to each punt... mf/mff etc.

Get tapping away. Remember.... you're writing the review for US and not for her... you'll be fine then 

One punter redt4 in the East midlands has reviewed his lover/wife/product or what ever else she may be to him in 6 out of 10 reviews has her in !

Admin does lose patience with obsessives like he did with spkmstr48 here https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=79536.msg990635#msg990635

[cueball]

One punter redt4 in the East midlands has reviewed his lover/wife/product or what ever else she may be to him in 6 out of 10 reviews has her in !

Admin does lose patience with obsessives like he did with spkmstr48 here https://www.ukpunting.com/index.php?topic=79536.msg990635#msg990635

To me, multiple reviews of the same lass by the same punter in the same scenario lose credibilty for both.

I have a policy of never reviewing the same lass twice unless there's something fundamentally different..  that can be a change in quality of service/a threesome or a short snappy one on a change of location.

Reviews are meant to be for us the punters

[stevedave]

To me, multiple reviews of the same lass by the same punter in the same scenario lose credibilty for both.

I have a policy of never reviewing the same lass twice unless there's something fundamentally different..  that can be a change in quality of service/a threesome or a short snappy one on a change of location.

Reviews are meant to be for us the punters

Completely agreed, same way I look at it.

[mrdiamond77]

At present I have yet to review any girl more than once.  I am thinking about reviewing again the first girl I reviewed after I joined this site as there has been such a long gap between reviews, plus I have seen her many times since and her service has not only not dipped but has got even better as she now knows what I like.

[Sureshot]

To me, multiple reviews of the same lass by the same punter in the same scenario lose credibilty for both.

I have a policy of never reviewing the same lass twice unless there's something fundamentally different..  that can be a change in quality of service/a threesome or a short snappy one on a change of location.

Reviews are meant to be for us the punters

I wouldnt even bother reviewing for a change of location, a simple regional post is enough. Unless you invite the doorman to join you, the premesis has little relevance to how good a fuck she is.

I would (and have) reviewed the same girl when shes used a new profile and linked to the old one.  A lot of important infomation can go unoticed if she changes the 7 digit number.

[vw]

At present I have yet to review any girl more than once.  I am thinking about reviewing again the first girl I reviewed after I joined this site as there has been such a long gap between reviews, plus I have seen her many times since and her service has not only not dipped but has got even better as she now knows what I like.

she got banned for making threats via pm, any idea what that was about ?

Gutted not to get one myself.   

[smiths]

I have not posted any reviews yet. I have had three punts since oct. One punt was with two wgs - which I've already commented on , the 2nd punt was with one of the wgs from the two girl punt, but she was just on her own (thank fuck) . 3rd punt today and fresh in mind, balls emptied i'm in reviewing mood and want to review all three wgs . So post what I can remeber of the two girl punt back in oct, post last weeks (2nd punt) and post todays punt!

lotta of reviewing

Admin once posted it was up to a punter to decide for himself and others will judge, he did though say dont take the piss which I took to mean don't keep reviewing the same WG all the time. So its up to you.

[hullad]

I see a wg regular, in between I see a fresh one and so far I have made a report on each of those.

I have never done a report on her as she only see's a few (and getting fewer) clients. Doing a report on her every time would be boring to write and dull as ditchwater to read.

[NervousJ]

Agreed, I've cut down to a regular and one newbie per month. It would seem pointless reviewing the same girl again. Unless I tried something completely different and I thought others might like to know...

It's bloody hard work though, I reckon I might up it to 3 per month.....

[Spunky34]

I would only review the same girl twice if either service levels declined hugely or if it had been a long time (over a year, for sure) since I last met her.  No point in reviewing regulars who you see very frequently and are consistently satisfied with - chances are that the service may not be representative of what it would be like for someone else.

The other danger with frequent reviews of regulars is potentially getting a bit too used to them and either not noticing or turning a blind eye to slight downturns in levels of service over repeated visits.  I always think the most helpful and representative review will be about the first time you meet a girl.

[pewpewpew]

I think it depends on time scale as well. If I saw a girl twice one year apart I would review again only if there were no  other reviews. If others had seen her and confirmed my experience then I'm not adding anything.

Have to say though that a review from a year ago loses a lot of credibility as girls change so if there is a significant gap and nobody else has been reviewing her then that up to date review, even if just to say that she was as good (or bad) as before is useful to me

[Steely Dan]

As pewpew said. It is all about helping other punters, not keeping score for her or you.  What will we learn from the second review?  If a MFF (vs a MF), could be a lot!  But in some situations, consider just replying to your other post.

I choose to do a second one of an escort after 2 years since I thought it was helpful to show excellent service maintained.  Maybe I'll review her again in another 2 years. Or maybe reply to my last review, both work.

[munterhunter]

I have reviewed the same girl more than once but it has been months between the reviews. If there's something different between the punts like mf mmf mff or a different service or change in her performance then I'd note that
In the review.  If someone regularly reviews the same girl saying the same things..do we really need admin to get involved?  We have enough experience and common sense to see it for what it is and either ignore it or respond to let the op know what he's up to

[5th Musketeer]

I have not posted any reviews yet. I have had three punts since oct. One punt was with two wgs - which I've already commented on , the 2nd punt was with one of the wgs from the two girl punt, but she was just on her own (thank fuck) . 3rd punt today and fresh in mind, balls emptied i'm in reviewing mood and want to review all three wgs . So post what I can remeber of the two girl punt back in oct, post last weeks (2nd punt) and post todays punt!

lotta of reviewing

Tried to send you a PM but you can't receive them. You may have revealed your AW id here.