How to review a WG who I just saw...?

[zinger]

So guys,

Bit of a challenging one for me.

The other day I saw an escort who had either very photo shopped or very old photos, as she had gained a very noticeable waist line when I met her. So, that would be a negative, inaccurate photos, right?

Here is the thing - that was the only problem. She had one of the best attitudes I encountered in a while, being super friendly and chatty/funny. She also had the best BJ technique I had also encountered in a while... great DT with tongue action and suction also. Regardless of the bit of extra weight, she is still beautiful to me.

I am challenged.. because a misleading photos are verrrrry bad imho but I don't want the other stuff discounted either and a negative is not good for the girl at all.

I'm just thinking out loud here really... but what would you go with?

FWIW - I am veering towards negative if I am honest.

[tesla]

your review your rating, but you have already decided I think

[Blackpool Rock]

I prefer petite girls myself so turning expecting a size 8 gym bunny only to find a size 14 couch potato is a major bug bare with me.
It's a quandary really as based on her service alone it sound like she would have got a Positive so giving a Negative does seem harsh.

Personally i'd probably put all the facts in about her service / attitude being great but her profile stats and pics being out of date / misleading, on that basis punters can decide for themselves and someone who doesn't mind a size XYZ can still punt her based on service alone and those who don't like size XYZ can avoid

Sounds like a Neutral as a compromise 

[Foxtail17]

I prefer petite girls myself so turning expecting a size 8 gym bunny only to find a size 14 couch potato is a major bug bare with me.
It's a quandary really as based on her service alone it sound like she would have got a Positive so giving a Negative does seem harsh.

Personally i'd probably put all the facts in about her service / attitude being great but her profile stats and pics being out of date / misleading, on that basis punters can decide for themselves and someone who doesn't mind a size XYZ can still punt her based on service alone and those who don't like size XYZ can avoid

Sounds like a Neutral as a compromise 

Sounds like good advice.

[whiskyfan]

The rating isn't that important IMO. Just write the review with the facts and let the reader decide what rating they would apply according to their own criteria. I've read plenty of reviews on here where I've come to a different conclusion on the rating than the reviewer did. I'm sure the same probably applies to a few of mine.

[threechilliman]

The rating isn't that important IMO. Just write the review with the facts and let the reader decide what rating they would apply according to their own criteria. I've read plenty of reviews on here where I've come to a different conclusion on the rating than the reviewer did. I'm sure the same probably applies to a few of mine.

+1. Read the review and make your own mind up.

[daviemac]

OP, it's your review, it's up to you what rating to give it, what others would do in your perceived situation is irrelevant.  You were the one in the booking no one else, it was your experience, once ratings are decided by others the site becomes pointless.

Just give an accurate and honest account of how it went, if you feel there were negative points say there were negative points. What you find unacceptable and what others might find unacceptable are two totally different things.

Members will read your review and take from it the information they find useful.

[Hungarian Lover]

If the whole experience was good for you and you left feeling satisfied then for you it rated a positive, just leave all the positive and negatives in your review. I always thing that if it was a really good punt then I probably would see her again. 

[signy]

How did you feel as you walked out the door? Did you leave thinking it was a good punt, bad punt or inbetween? That immediate emotional response determines your +/0/- rating.

All the good parts and bad parts can then be detailed in the review, so that other punters can make up their own minds if those are aspects important to them.

[Hobbit]

As others have said, you can rate it whatever you like but you need to give an accurate description of the event, the girl and the photos. If you are saying that the photos were not accurate then please explain how in the review.

[houseboot]

Sounds like a "Positive" to me as her service & attitude was first class.

Just needs a comment that photos are not up to date.


If her photos were accurate and the service was crap would you have voted Positive (as photos) or Negative (service was crap)?


The Service is the key element, I want good service not a prima donna model.

[Fuzzyduck]

Personally I think it depends on where you sit on the looks vs service axis. For me, whilst looks are important, service wins. However, others are very clear about what physicality they desire since it stimulates what's going on in their heads.

I'd probably rate positive in a similar scenario to you. The model chasers would have walked and given a neg. As others have said, just be objective and don't worry if anyone suggests they would have rated neutral or neg if a SP had turned out to be porkier than they expected.

[xyfek]

I understand the dilemma. We create expectations of who we're going to meet, and it can often be disappointing. Both looks and service wise.

I tend to value service over looks, so as long as the girl isn't a complete munter, and the experience was a good one, I'd give a positive. Of course, you should make it clear that the photos are very outdated and then the rest of us can decide whether to take a punt on her or not.

[NickyBobby]

If it a different woman to the photos, negative
If it’s the same woman but gained weight but you still went through with the booking, your choice but I would rate positive/neutral if I stayed and received services depending if I would go back again
If she’s gained weight and you choose not to go ahead, negative

[Mothball15]

If you don’t want to be identified then change the little details of the meet such as:
Time of meet
Sex positions
Even how she looked.

Therefore you can meet again
Without any comeback.

[cunningman]

Here is the thing - that was the only problem. She had one of the best attitudes I encountered in a while, being super friendly and chatty/funny. She also had the best BJ technique I had also encountered in a while... great DT with tongue action and suction also. Regardless of the bit of extra weight, she is still beautiful to me.

The service was good, and she's still beautiful to you?  Clear positive for me.

If you expect every SP to post photos that are warts and all and recent, then you may be in for a life of disappointment - and you will miss out on some great shags.

For a start, if the profile is 10 years old, there's a good chance the photos are too.

But - its your review.

[contentguy]

Your review, your rating.
But it sounds like you had a good time, she was enthusiastic.

Positive for me, but mention pics being out of date.

Guy

[RAJEC]

Go down the middle with a neutral.

Positive for the service, negative for the misleading information.

Covers all bases 

[Grumpy Pumpy]

You could make a strong case for positive. And a strong case for neutral.

I think a neg would be harsh.

But, ultimately, it's only your opinion that matters. As it was your punt

[Bonker]

Here's an analogy:
If I'm not sure I like a particular single malt, I pour myself another tot.

Go fuck her again, then write a review.

[Blackpool Rock]

Go down the middle with a neutral.

Positive for the service, negative for the misleading information.

Covers all bases 

That was my take on it too, another thing here is that if her stats / pics are so out of date / misleading then it's effectively not far off of being a B&S really is it 

[mrfishyfoo]

It's how they fuck not how they look that matters. 

BUT, and as others have stated, if the pictures are that far out then that needs addressing.

I "swing" from size 6 to size 14 so size, if I know about it, ain't an issue albeit if I was expecting a 6 and got a 14 I'd walk.

Hope that helps MrZ.