LL, I am grateful for the opportunity to return to the discussion with you about TOFTT where we can have a constructive debate. As you know, unlike you I think TOFTT is important and to be celebrated. Here is why.
I think your argument is that there is no sacrifice associated with a TOFTT review. I fundamentally disagree. TOFTT punts are certainly more risky than punting WG's who have existing reviews. If I look at my own case of the handful of reviews I have done which are TOFTT, only one of those is positive review. This is against my run rate for general reviews of about 50% positive (I am a sloppy researcher and opportunistic by force of circumstance). I think the risk of wasting money on an unsatisfactory punt is much greater with TOFTT.
Secondly, quite apart from the greater risk of a TOFTT punt, it is self sacrificing to publish a review where the review draws attention and increased custom to the WG. In my own case, I only saw a TOFTT punt twice before she increased her rates by 50%. So, if my review played a part in making her more popular, I lost out for publishing the review.
The reason I value TOFTT reviews is that they are absolutely vital to the value and quality of this board. There are plenty of fuckers on UKP who never write reviews, who sponge parasitically of the contributors and give nothing back. Only slightly better are those will write 5 or more reviews of the same girl trotting out the same bland story of how she is young, beautiful, slim and offers great service regardless of the truth. They benefit no one except themselves and the WG's they promote.
Contrast these time-wasting useless arseholes to those members who take the risk, invest their own time and money, and then share it back with us for our benefit so we can get better punts. I think they are heroes. I will recognise and thank them for their contribution. They help me make better decisions about where to punt.
"Take One For The Team"? Too right they do.
Dave