I think that providing the writer isn't writing some kind of advert for the prossie I don't care what writing style they use. We're all different. Look at who we see and what we look for.
The only thing that I would object to is people jumping on a bandwagon and trying to give someone a label like 'fluffy' just because they don't write in the style someone else likes or because they don't have the same level of experience.
Someone may have had anal sex with a girl. Fine. I don't want to read details about his hairy arse bouncing up and down. If that's how they want to write about it, then that's up to them and I'd defend their right to do that. I'd rather they write something than be scared off.
Attacking someone for their writing style will just scare people off writing a review. I'd rather read a review in any style than not be able to find one because some members have silenced others.