I've seen her recently
If punters are leaving fake reviews. It damages the integrity of the forum
She has provided evidence so far
Like I said, I've seen her and she's not a size 18, nowhere close so that is a lie.
Taking your points...
The fact you have sen her makes you biased, I'm not, I am simply looking at it objectively.
The integrity of the forum, exactly, and that is upheld by questioning matters, just because you've fucked the girl doesn't mean the review must be fake, pro$$ies do lie, particularly when they get a bad review.
Her "evidence" a train ticket to MK on a Fridy evening, proves nothing.
As for she's not a size 18, well take her to M & S and see if she can get into a size 14 pair of jeans, when she can't see what size she does need, and that's based on the pictures she's posted on her profile, so the size comment does not make him a liar.
A appreciate you are biased, but don't be so keen to shout fake just because she has, she's being given the opportunity to state her case as he is also, let it run it's course, the truth will out, just don't start white knighting the girl as one thing is for sure, you don't know what happened and if the meet took place or not, only what she tells you.