Now let me get this straight. You put the lime in the coconut...
You went to see girl A, but got bait & switched with girl B, whom you rejected.
You then got girl C, whom you decided to see, but don't have a link for.
You don't know if girl A was actually on-site or not but A, B & C are all Roms by the sounds of it.
Mr Punt then confuses the matter by introducing girl D, who isn't girl A, but just happens to have a similar moniker to her, and is in another location.
Actually not that confusing.
Glad you had a good punt, but IMO it's a straight negative for the B&S. Many people will only see the positive flag against girl A and not the detail. You could've done a new review with a positive on girl C, but you don't have any details to make it worth doing.