In which case I would suggest deleting it and starting again on an open basis
i think the lads who have access quite like it how it is. Its a community within a community and doesn't really have any arguments now at all, which is good going.
If it was deleted it would be a shame. I've used it almost as a blog space, sharing experiences as they come along. its nice to reflect back personally.
Suppose it being closed is a little selfish - but often new members to the thead who joined the thread were cranks or lurkers at best, white knights at worse relaying info.
Think a poster joining the thread having certain thresholds could be an idea (joined over x amount of time ago. contributed reviews or certain amount of posts over time etc).
Personally having most posts about SA 'public' would be trouble for the girls themselves, as well as drama for girls that get discussed - i don't want to sound like a shite knight, but they often join SA naively and dont realize what its really about. Plenty get bullshitted and manipulated by having men fucking them and not giving them agreed funds -playing on the girls own self fear of coming over sex worker like. Its a shitty stick more often than not for them. I know the vast majority I've met would be mortified at the prospect of someone discussing them on a punting forum (as hypocritical as this makes me, discussing even in the closed format). Someone sharing details on here of girls and potentially outting them seems unfair