Did you have a GFE with Amber Coast?
Where is your review?
Just curious why, are you posting the same question on multiple threads, the OP hasn't been a member 2 weeks yet.
Do you do this with every newbie.
I saw Amber Coast 3 years ago so she's been around for a while, have you ever thought it might have been more than 6 months ago when he saw her, so he couldn't review even if he wanted to but the comment he made on the other thread was useful information.
How about giving the newbies a bit of encouragement, even if they do start 'unusual' threads, instead of following them around the forum demanding reviews. The OP may turn out to be a useful contributor, once he's got a bit used to the site, if given the chance.