Advice of Review - New thread or add to exisiting?

[soysauce]

I am after some advice regarding a review that I am about to post.

The question is, SHOULD THIS BE A NEW REVIEW OR SHOULD IT BE ADDED AS A REPLY ON AN EXISTING REVIEW?

I have returned to see the same lady for a massage that I have already reviewed before. She still has her old adverts but she also has new adverts now, with different titles, although the phone number remained the same.

However, the second visit was better than the first visit even though I would give both visits a positive. The main reason for asking for advice is, I have used a different strategy from comms to payment in order to have a more sexy service.

Should I just add to an existing review or just start a new one?

[Rochelle]

I am after some advice regarding a review that I am about to post.

The question is, SHOULD THIS BE A NEW REVIEW OR SHOULD IT BE ADDED AS A REPLY ON AN EXISTING REVIEW?

I have returned to see the same lady for a massage that I have already reviewed before. She still has her old adverts but she also has new adverts now, with different titles, although the phone number remained the same.

However, the second visit was better than the first visit even though I would give both visits a positive. The main reason for asking for advice is, I have used a different strategy from comms to payment in order to have a more sexy service.

Should I just add to an existing review or just start a new one?

Add it to the existing review, just like it states in the rules.

[king tarzan]

i saw sophia sky, i just added it to my existing thread about her..

[daviemac]

Add it to the existing review, just like it states in the rules.

+ 1
In case you don't know them, the link's at the bottom of every page.

 - Reviews
A new review thread can only be created once a service provider has agreed to a booking (e.g. verbally or by textual messaging). A meet does not need to take place, money does not need change hands, the only requirement is that the she had accepted the initial booking. Only one review thread is permissible per punt. Do not combine multiple punts in the same review thread, neither should a single punt be split into multiple review threads. Do not post the same review in multiple regions. Only sex workers can be the subject of a review, not a whole agency / establishment / brothel. Past or current sex workers or anyone related to a sex worker (e.g. boyfriend) may not review any other sex worker. Reviews must contain either a link, contact details or address (if publicised by the service provider). Massage-only reviews without any sexual services are permitted, but ideally should make it clear in the topic title. Only one positive review thread can be posted for a service provider by one member per 12 month period, the exception is if the new positive review is for a threesome or more booking. This 12-month restriction only applies to positive reviews, not neutral or negative (they can be posted anytime after a positive review). During the 12-month period a member can add their new positive reviews to their existing review thread in the form of a reply.

[LLPunting]

You only need to post a new review if you're changing the rating you gave her and want to tell us about what she did differently to the previous encounter. 

There is a minimum time that needs to pass between successive reviews for the same SP (regardless of new name, ad or profile) that are the same rating but I would suggest that it's always best to just add to your old review if it's the same rating and similar performance.

[soysauce]

Thank you guys, I will add to the review then.

[daviemac]

You only need to post a new review if you're changing the rating you gave her and want to tell us about what she did differently to the previous encounter. 

There is a minimum time that needs to pass between successive reviews for the same SP (regardless of new name, ad or profile) that are the same rating but I would suggest that it's always best to just add to your old review if it's the same rating and similar performance.

That's not strictly true, it's only positive's that need to be a year apart you can post as many negs and neutrals as you like.

[Steely Dan]

That's not strictly true, it's only positive's that need to be a year apart you can post as many negs and neutrals as you like.

But if you have 2 negatives from the same escort, then shame on you.  I know it can be a negative for no show, and then negative for bad service, but still....