Actually, I kind-of miss the old curmudgeon!
So do I. I never understood why a few people didn't like him. If he was a troll, then he was the best possible troll to ever have. As he always made my laugh out loud with his humour. Very few people achieve that. But James always could. He was also always right on the money with his punting advice/tips. I always had him down as the guy to listen to if people were disagreeing on what to do in a particular scenario
In terms of the lack of reviews, what people may not know is this forum was setup by a core group of known respected punters who were all active on P---net and came over here together to build up this place from scratch. James was known, and respected punter on there and had been around there for many years. He used a different username on there to here though.
This is why people liked him here even though on the face of it, he didn't review. As he was known and respected from elsewhere.
I also believe oldAdmin allowed him to review under another name (the ACP historical IP logins can confirm that fact too if needed).
Like I said on another topic, we actually once had a poll to see whether he should be banned or not. The only time a poll like this was used. He survived by flying colours as everyone liked him.
That was rumoured but never proven.
A rumour that was started by OldAdmin himself if I recall. You could kind of take that as more than a rumour if so.