No, I was merely expressing an opinion. It's allowed.
I agree that other reviews are important. Sadly, the OP hasn't written this as a review, which makes it of limited value as it won't appear with a Negative, Neutral or Positive rating, so people's attention won't be easily drawn to the issues he raises. Making these comments in the discussion section means that they get missed when someone is looking through her reviews.
If you want to write a review then write a review. He was told it was fine to write another review and he hasn't done it.
And while we're at it OP, you've been on this site since 2017 and you've contributed a grand total of 6 reviews and your first review was in 2021 and you said you've been seeing SPs for 25 years. We seem to be missing a lot of reviews from you. I have contributed 27 reviews.