I think the point of a hotlist of girls (whether mental or written down) is that it's constantly evolving & changing and not something you need to stick to rigidly. I punt with whoever takes my fancy most at any given time, surely that's the point of punting, to have fun with who you want when you want.
If you meant a bucketlist of punting ideas (different services like anal, DP, T&T or different nationalities to meet, various specialisms or fetishes to try), then you might look for chances to tick them off your list as and when the opportunity arises, but I wouldn't pass up a good opportunity to meet a nice girl who I really fancied just because she didn't offer whatever was next on my 'list'.